Welcome to the State Water Resources Control Board Welcome to the California Environmental Protection Agency
Governor's Website Visit the Water Board Members Page
Agendas
My Water Quality
Performance Report
Storm Water Program

Storm Water Program

Phase II Small Municipal Permit

PUBLIC COMMENTS REGARDING PHASE II SMALL MS4 GENERAL PERMIT

The State Water Board invited the public to comment on the draft Tentative Order for the Phase II Small MS4 General Permit (June 2011).  The Water Board staff subsequently responded to the public comments. The numbered, annotated version of the comment letters correspond to numbers in the staff's Response to Comments document.

Number Company Representative's
Original Letter
Representative's
Annotated Version
1 Atascadero Unified School District Deborah Bowers Deborah Bowers
2 Bay Area Stormwater Management Agencies James Scanlin James Scanlin
3 Bay-Friendly Landscaping & Gardening Coalition Anne Cook Anne Cook
4 Belli Architectural Group Raymond Belli Raymond Belli
5 BNSF Railway Edward Phillips Edward Phillips (2.7 MB)
6 Butte County Board of Supervisors Steve Lambert Steve Lambert
7 Calaveras County Public Works Robert Pachinger Robert Pachinger
8 California Association of School Business Officials Dennis Meyers Dennis Meyers
9 California Chamber of Commerce Valerie Nera Valerie Nera
10 California Coalition for Adequate School Housing Kathy Tanner Kathy Tanner
11 California Council for Environmental and Economic Balance Robert Lucas
Gerald Secundy
Robert Lucas
Gerald Secundy
12 California County Superintendents Educational Services Association Michael Hulsizer Michael Hulsizer
13 California Grocers Association
California Retailers Association
California Restaurant Associatio
Kara Bush
Missy Johnson
Matthew Sutton
Kara Bush
Missy Johnson
Matthew Sutton
14 California State Association of Counties
Regional Council of Rural Counties
League of California Cities
Karen Keene
Staci Heaton
Kyra Ross
Karen Keene
Staci Heaton
Kyra Ross
15 California State Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation Chris Meyer Chris Meyer
16 California State Department of Parks and Recreation Anthony Perez
Daphne Greene
Anthony Perez
Daphne Greene
(1.7 MB)
17 California Stormwater Quality Association Scott Taylor Scott Taylor (1.6 MB)
18 Central Coast Long-Term Environmental Assessment Network Dane Hardin Dane Hardin
19 Central Valley Clean Water Association Debbie Webster Debbie Webster
20 Citadel Equities Group, LLC. Sheri Taylor Sheri Taylor
21 City of Arroyo Grande Teresa McClish Teresa McClish
22 City of Atascadero Russell Thompson Russell Thompson
23 City of Banning Duane Burk Duane Burk
24 City of Buelton Rose Hess Rose Hess
25 City of Carmel by the Sea Sean Conroy Sean Conroy
26 City of Ceres Toby Wells Toby Wells
27 City of Cloverdale Gus Wolter Gus Wolter
28 City of El Paso de Robles Matt Thompson Matt Thompson
29 City of Healdsburg Michael Kim Michael Kim
30 City of Lompoc John Linn John Linn (1.9 MB)
31 City of Malibu Jim Thorsen Jim Thorsen
32 City of Monterey Chuck Della Sala Chuck Della Sala
33 City of Morro Bay Williamm Yates Williamm Yates
34 City of Napa Jill Techel Jill Techel (1.1 MB)
35 City of Patterson Rod Butler Rod Butler
36 City of Pismo Beach Shelly Higginbotham Shelly Higginbotham
37 City of Redding Kurt Starman Kurt Starman
38 City of Riverbank J.D. Hightower J.D. Hightower
39 City of Rocklin Rick Horst Rick Horst
40 City of Roseville Pauline Roccucci Pauline Roccucci (2.2 MB)
41 City of San Diego Transportation & Storm Water Department Kris McFadden Kris McFadden
42 City of San Luis Obispo Katie Lichtig Katie Lichtig
43 City of Santa Barbara Cameron Benson Cameron Benson
44 City of Santa Clarita Travis Lange Travis Lange
45 City of Santa Maria Richard Sweet Richard Sweet (1.5 MB)
46 City of Santa Rosa Miles Ferris Miles Ferris
47 City of Sonoma Linda Kelly Linda Kelly
48 City of Sonoma Wendy Atkins
Milenka Bates
Wendy Atkins
Milenka Bates
49 City of Tracy R. Leon Churchill R. Leon Churchill (2.6 MB)
50 City of Turlock Dan Madden Dan Madden
51 City of Ukiah Tim Eriksen Tim Eriksen
52 City of Vacaville Royce Cunningham Royce Cunningham
53 City of Watsonville Daniel Dodge Daniel Dodge
54 City of Wheatland Dane Schilling Dane Schilling
55 City of Woodland Mark Deven Mark Deven
56 City of Yreka Rory McNeil Rory McNeil
57 Coalition for Practical Regulation Larry Forester Larry Forester (1.3 MB)
58 College of the Canyons Carl Ebaugh Carl Ebaugh
59 Contra Costa Community College District Ray Pyle Ray Pyle
60 Contractors Association of Truckee Tahoe Pat Davison Pat Davison
61 County of El Dorado James Ware James Ware
62 County of Kern Kevin Hamilton
Charles Lackey
Kevin Hamilton
Charles Lackey
(1.1 MB)
63 County of Los Angeles, Department of Public Works Gail Farber Gail Farber
64 County of Mendocino Kendall Smith Kendall Smith
65 County of Riverside Michael Shelter Michael Shelter
66 County of San Bernardino Granville Bowman Granville Bowman (1.5 MB)
67 County of San Luis Obispo Adam Hill Adam Hill
68 County of Santa Barbara Chandra Wallar Chandra Wallar
69 County of Santa Clara Jody Hall Esser Jody Hall Esser
70 County of Santa Cruz John Presleigh
Robert Kennedy
John Presleigh
Robert Kennedy
71 County of Sonoma Reg Cullen Reg Cullen
72 County School Facilities Consortium Anna Ferrera Anna Ferrera
73 Department of Defense, Region 9 CL Stathos CL Stathos
74 Department of the Navy Patricia McFadden Patricia McFadden
75 Downey Unified School District Buck Weinfurter Buck Weinfurter
76 FAMCO Holdings Brendan Finn Brendan Finn
77 Gallinas Watershed Council Russ Greenfield Russ Greenfield
78 General Public Bruce Lund Bruce Lund
79 General Public Joyce Dillard Joyce Dillard
80 General Public Teresa Jordan Teresa Jordan
81 Hemet Unified School District Steven Lowder Steven Lowder
82 Humboldt Baykeeper Beth Werner
Michelle Smith
Beth Werner
Michelle Smith
83 Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory Bruce Schultz Bruce Schultz
84 Los Angeles Community Colleges Tom Hall Tom Hall (2.9 MB)
85 Los Angeles County Office of Education Pamela Gibbs Pamela Gibbs
86 Los Angeles Department of Water and Power Katherine Rubin Katherine Rubin
87 Los Angeles Unified School District Richard Luke Richard Luke
88 Los Osos Community Service District Dan Gilmore Dan Gilmore
89 Lucia Mar Unified School District Kevin Baker Kevin Baker
90 MacKay & Somps Ken Giberson Ken Giberson
91 Marin Conservation League Susan Stompe Susan Stompe
92 Marin County Department of Public Works Terri Fashing Terri Fashing
93 Mendocino County Office of Education Paul Tichinin
Vicki Todd
Stephen Turner
Paul Tichinin
Vicki Todd
Stephen Turner
94 Mendocino County Office of Education Paul Tichinin Paul Tichinin
95 Mojave River Watershed Group Nancy Sansonetti Nancy Sansonetti (1.6 MB)
96 Monterey County Department of Public Works Thomas Harty Thomas Harty
97 Monterey County Hospitality Association Janine Chicourrat Janine Chicourrat
98 Monterey County Mayors’ Association David Pendergrass David Pendergrass
99 Monterey Regional Stormwater Permit Participants Group Sydney Moe Sydney Moe
100 Napa Chamber of Commerce Ryan Gregory
Lisa Batto
Ryan Gregory
Lisa Batto
101 Napa County Flood Control and Water Conservation District Jill Techel Jill Techel
102 Natural Resource Defense Council
Heal the Bay
California Coastkeeper Alliance
Noah Garrison
Kirsten James
Sara Aminzadeh
Noah Garrison
Kirsten James
Sara Aminzadeh
103 NG Alexander Real Estate Development LLC N.G. Alexander N.G. Alexander
104 Nine Mile Hill Investment Company Michael George Michael George (1.3 MB)
105 North Bay Watershed Association Jack Gibson Jack Gibson
106 Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment George Alexeeff George Alexeeff
107 Orange County Department of Education Andrea Sullivan Andrea Sullivan
108 Paso Robles Public Schools Kathleen McNamara Kathleen McNamara
109 Peninsula Corridor Joint Powers Board Chuck Harvey Chuck Harvey
110 Placer County Department of Public Works Ken Grehm Ken Grehm (2.8 MB)
111 Placer Regional Stormwater Coordination Group
Placer County
City of Roseville
City of Rocklin
City of Lincoln
City of Auburn
Town of Loomis
Ken Grehm
Pauline Roccucci
George Magnuson
Jim Estep
Bernie Schroder
Perry Beck
Ken Grehm
Pauline Roccucci
George Magnuson
Jim Estep
Bernie Schroder
Perry Beck
112 Port of San Francisco
City and County of San Francisco Public Utilities Commission
Monique Moyer
Tommy Moala
Monique Moyer
Tommy Moala
113 Richland Communities Clifton Taylor Clifton Taylor
114 Riverside County Flood Control and Water Conservation District Jason Uhley Jason Uhley (2.4 MB)
115 Riverside County Transportation Department Juan Perez Juan Perez
116 Russian River Watershed Association Jake Mackenzie Jake Mackenzie
117 Sacramento Stormwater Quality Partnership Richard Lorenz Richard Lorenz
118 San Diego County Office of Education Municipal Stormwater Group Joanne Branch Joanne Branch
119 San Diego Regional Water Quality Control Board David Barker David Barker
120 San Diego Unified School District – Facilities Planning & Construction James Watts James Watts
121 San Diego Unified School District Auxiliary Services Drew Rowlands Drew Rowlands
122 San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District Nancy Lowenthal Nancy Lowenthal
123 San Francisco Baykeeper Jason Flanders
Ian Wren
Abigail Blodgett
Jason Flanders
Ian Wren
Abigail Blodgett
124 San Gabriel Unified School District Ralph Patterson Ralph Patterson
125 San Luis Costal Unified School District Russell Miller Russell Miller
126 San Mateo County Transit District Chuck Harvey Chuck Harvey
127 Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District Janece Maez Janece Maez
128 Signature Homes Stephen Hicks Stephen Hicks
129 Solano County Department of Resource Management Matt Tuggle
Nicholas Burton
Matt Tuggle
Nicholas Burton
130 Sonoma Valley Chamber of Commerce Jennifer Yankovich Jennifer Yankovich
131 Specialty Steel Service Joseph McCaslin Joseph McCaslin
132 Stanislaus County Laurie Barton Laurie Barton
133 Stanislaus County Matt Machado Matt Machado (5.2 MB)
134 Statewide Stormwater Coalition:
City of Atascadero
City of Carmel by the Sea
City of Davi
City of Auburn
City of Ceres
City of Del Rey Oaks
City of Lincoln
City of Pacific Grove
City of San Luis Obispo
City of Lodi
City of Paso Robles
City of Sand City
City of Lompoc
City of Patterson
City of Santa Maria
City of Marina
City of Pismo Beach
City of Seaside
City of Monterey
City of Placerville
City of Sonoma
City of Morro Bay
City of Riverbank
City of Tracy
City of Napa
City of Rocklin
City of Watsonville
City of Newman
City of Roseville
City of Woodland
City of Yuba City
County of San Bernardino
County of Yolo
Town of Loomis
County of San Luis Obispo
California Chapters of the American Public
Works Association
Town of Truckee
County of Santa Cruz
California State Association of Counties
County of Butte
County of Shasta
League of California Cities
County of Monterey
County of Sonoma
Regional Council of Rural Counties
County of Placer
County of Stanislaus
Shasta County Water Agency
Russell Thompson
John Goss
William Marshall
Bernie Schroeder
Chris Vierra
Jerry Edelen
Jim Estep
Thomas Frutchey
Jan Marx
Konradt Bartlam
Matt Thompson
Richard Simonitch
Laurel Barcelona
Rod Butler
Larry Lavagnino
Anthony Altfeld
Shelly Higginbotham
Ray Corpuz
Chuck Della Sala
M. Cleve Morris
Linda Kelly
Andrea Lueker
JD Hightower
Brent Ives
Jill Techel
George Magnuson
Robert Ketley
Garner Reynolds
Pauline Roccucci
Mark Deven
Steve Jepsen
Granville Bowman
Matt Rexroad
Perry Beck
Adam Hill
Doug Fredericks Tony Lashbrook
John Presleigh
Karen Keene
Mike Crump
Patrick Minturn
Kyra Ross
Yazdan Emrani
Reg Cullen
Staci Heaton
Ken Grehm
Mat Machado
Patrict Minturn
Russell Thompson
John Goss
William Marshall
Bernie Schroeder
Chris Vierra
Jerry Edelen
Jim Estep
Thomas Frutchey
Jan Marx
Konradt Bartlam
Matt Thompson
Richard Simonitch
Laurel Barcelona
Rod Butler
Larry Lavagnino
Anthony Altfeld
Shelly Higginbotham
Ray Corpuz
Chuck Della Sala
M. Cleve Morris
Linda Kelly
Andrea Lueker
JD Hightower
Brent Ives
Jill Techel
George Magnuson
Robert Ketley
Garner Reynolds
Pauline Roccucci
Mark Deven
Steve Jepsen
Granville Bowman
Matt Rexroad
Perry Beck
Adam Hill
Doug Fredericks Tony Lashbrook
John Presleigh
Karen Keene
Mike Crump
Patrick Minturn
Kyra Ross
Yazdan Emrani
Reg Cullen
Staci Heaton
Ken Grehm
Mat Machado
Patrict Minturn
(3.5 MB)
135 Sun City Roseville Homeowners Association Jeanne Clark Jeanne Clark
136 Tallman Communities Real Estate Development & Entitlements John Tallman John Tallman
137 The Otter Project
Monterey Coastkeeper
Steve Shimek Steve Shimek
138 Todd Engineers Raymond Will Raymond Will
139 Town of Paradise Alan White Alan White
140 Town of Truckee Richard Anderson Richard Anderson (2.6 MB)
141 Town of Windsor Richard Burtt Richard Burtt
142 United States Environmental Protection Agency, Region 9 David Smith David Smith
143 University of California Robert Charbonneau Robert Charbonneau
144 Valley Contractors Exchange Kate Leyden Kate Leyden
145 Ventura County Office of Education Ken Prosser Ken Prosser
146 WateReuse California David Smith David Smith
147 Weiss Associates Scott Bourne
Agata Sulczynski
Bob Devany
Scott Bourne
Agata Sulczynski
Bob Devany
148 West Coast Housing Partners, LLC Rick Langdon Rick Langdon
149 Westpark Associates Jeff Jones Jeff Jones
150 Wood Rodgers Jennifer Hanson Jennifer Hanson
151 Woodland Chamber of Commerce Tom Galeazzi Tom Galeazzi
Date Late Comments   Representative
2/21/12 California Stormwater Quality Association   Richard Boon
12/16/11 California Stormwater Quality Association   Scott Taylor
Date Memorandum Disclosing CASQA Communication with State Board   Representative
05/25/12 CASQA and State Water Resources Control Board   State Water Board

For further information please contact:

Ali Dunn: (916) 341-6899 - adunn@waterboards.ca.gov
or
Eric Berntsen: (916) 341-5911 - eberntsen@waterboards.ca.gov
or
Christine Sotelo: (916) 322-1400 - csotelo@waterboards.ca.gov

 

 

 
 

.