Petition Requesting Changes in Water Rights of The Department of Water Resources and U.S. Bureau of Reclamation for the California WaterFix Project Hearing

File Transfer Protocol Site Information

The State Water Board developed a secure File Transfer Protocol (FTP) website where parties to the hearing should upload their exhibits and parties can download the exhibits submitted by other parties. Each party on the service list will be provided a party-specific account with a username and password before their exhibit submittal deadline. All parties to the hearing will also have access to a shared account on the FTP site, which will allow parties to view and download other parties' exhibits, but only after the exhibit submittal deadline. The shared account is accessible at https://ftp.waterboards.ca.gov/?u=water fix download&p=waterfix123.

Part 1 | Part 1 - Rebuttal | Part 1 - Sur-Rebuttal | Part 2 | Part 2 - Rebuttal | Part 2 - Sur-Rebuttal

Exhibit Identification Indexes and Transmittal Letters - Save the California Delta Alliance, et al.


Part 1 - Save the California Delta Alliance, et al's Case-in-Chief

Exhibit No. Exhibit Description Date Accepted into Evidence* or Withdrawn
SCDA-1 Aquatic Science Peer Review Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-2 8/19/2016 printout from Sacramento river flow Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-3 Handmade graph Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-4 Sacramento River at Freeport flow Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-5 Handmade graph Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-6 Panel Review by Jeffry Mount and Colleagues on BDCP Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-7 Challenges Facing the Sacramento San Joaquin River Delta Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-8 Delta Stewardship Council March 24, 2016, Agenda item 10 Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-9 Delta Science Program flow materials Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-10 March 19, 2004 letter from SWRCB to USBR and CCWD Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-11 Excerpt from Discovery Bay newspaper re algae blooms Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-12 Excerpt from Discovery Bay newspaper re algae blooms Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-13 CDEC Monitoring Stations Near Discovery Bay Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-17 D-1641 Compliance Stations Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-18 EC Graph Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_19 Delta Stewardship Council Cases Decision Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_20 Delta Stewardship Council Cases Minute Order   
scda_22 Testimony of Janet McCleery   
scda_24 Testimony of Michael Guzzardo Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_25 Testimony of Frank Morgan  
scda_26 August 26, 2014, USEPA Letter re BDCP Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_27 DWR Your Questions Answered pamphlet re BDCP Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_29 July 28, 2004, SWRCB Letter to USBR and DWR re water quality Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_30 Stats. 2001, C.320 Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_31 Climate Change and Water Security Cal. Energy Comm. Publication Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_32 Qualifications Erik Ringelberg Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_33 Testimony of Erik Ringelberg Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_34 October 30, 2015, USEPA Letter re CWF Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_35 Testimony of Tom Burke Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_36 Charts accompanying Burke testimony Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_37 Qaulifications of Tom Burke Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_38 Opening Statement  
scda_40 Delta Alliance October 30, 2015, BDCP comments Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_41 Delta Alliance July, 29, 2014, BDCP comments Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_42 DWR Bulletin 118 California Groundwater Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_43 DWR California Water Plan 2005 Groundwater Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_44 Designing successful groundbanking publication by NHI Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_45 Central valley conjunctive management publication by NHI Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_46 Groundwater and Surface Water in S. Cal. pubication by AGWA Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_47 Madera Irrigation District Water Supply Enhancement Project EIS Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_48 Testimony of Michael Brodsky
scda_49 Statement of qualifications Michael Brodsky Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_50 Powerpoint for use with opening statemnt and Burke and Brodsky testimony Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_51 SCDA comments on BDCP MOU Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_52 NHI Study of Maximal Groundwater Banking Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_53 Madera Irrigation District Groundwater Banking ROD Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_54 Sacrament River Flood Control Fact Sheet Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_55 Groundwater Management in California Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_56 Burke chart Old River at Tracy Road Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_57 Map of Monitoring Stations ECD, RSL, OBI, MDM Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_58 Station OBI Salinity Graph from DWR CDEC Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
scda_59 Station ECD Salinity Graph from DWR CDEC Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-60 Testimony of Michael Brodsky - Revised 10/17/2016  
SCDA-61 Testimony of Frank Morgan - Revised 10/17/2016  
SCDA-62 Testimony of Janet McCleery - Revised 10/17/2016  
SCDA-60-Errata Testimony of Michael Brodsky--Revised 10/17/2016 Errata - Revised 12/08/2016 Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-61-Errata Testimony of Frank Morgan--Revised 10/17/2016 Errata - Revised 12/08/2016 Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-62-Errata Testimony of Janet McCleery--Revised 10/17/2016 Errata - Revised 12/08/2016 Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-63 May 16, 2016 Status Report Letter from DWR to SWRCB - Added 12/08/2016 Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SCDA-64 July 19, 2016 Declaration of Michael Brodsky and Exhibits A (Chapter 3, January 2016 Draft BA); B (DWR March 11, 2016, Response to SWRCB requirement to address information requests); C (Simstead, et al., Aquatic Science Peer Review). - Added 12/08/2016 Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
Antioch_216 CCD 2010 Historic Delta Salinity Conditions Report  
DWR_117 CWF Draft Adaptive Management Framework  
SWRCB_21 SWRCB Water Rights Decision No. 1641  
SWRCB_46 Delta Stewardship Council, The Delta Plan Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SWRCB_49 Independent Science Board (ISB) Review of Environmental Documents for California WaterFix, September 30, 2015 Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SWRCB_104 Biological Assessment of the California WaterFix, July 2016 (Published August 2, 2016)  

 

Part 1 - Rebuttal

Exhibit No. Exhibit Description Date Accepted into Evidence* or Withdrawn
     

 

Part 1 - Sur-Rebuttal

Exhibit No. Exhibit Description Date Accepted into Evidence* or Withdrawn
     

 

Part 2

Exhibit No. Exhibit Description Date Accepted into Evidence* or Withdrawn
scda_65 Testimony of Charles Salter April 23, 2018 
scda_66 Statement of Qualifications for Charles Salter April 23, 2018 
scda_67 Intake #2 Noise Map April 23, 2018 
scda_68 Intake #3 Noise Map April 23, 2018 
scda_69 Intake #5 Noise Map April 23, 2018 
scda_70 Hood Intakes #3 and 5 Map April 23, 2018 
scda_71 Clarksburg Marina and Intake #2 Map April 23, 2018 
scda_72 Overview Map of three Intakes April 23, 2018 
scda_73 Map overview depiction of construction activity April 23, 2018 
scda_74 Charles Salter Associates July 12, 2017 comments on the FEIR/S April 23, 2018 
scda_75 Spring 2000 issue of Piledrivers.org Magazine April 23, 2018 
scda_76 Illington & Rodkin, Sound Levels Associated with Driving Steel Piles. April 23, 2018 
scda_77 T.J. Shultz, “Synthesis of Social Surveys on Noise Annoyance.” April 23, 2018 
scda_79 U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Criteria for a Recommended Standard, Occupational Noise Exposure, Revised Criteria 1998 April 23, 2018 
scda_80 Washington State Department of Transportation’s Biological Assessment Preparation Manual, Excerpts April 23, 2018 
scda_81 2006 Federal Transit Administration Transit Noise and Vibration Impact Assessment Manual Excerpts April 23, 2018 
scda_82 Biological Assessment, Appendix 3.E Pile Driving Assumptions for the Proposed Action April 23, 2018 
scda_83 Biological Assessment Appendix 3.D, Construction Schedule for the Proposed Action April 23, 2018 
scda_84 Bay Delta Conservation Plan / California WaterFix Final Environmental Impact Report, Response to Comments, Save the California Delta Alliance Comment Letter of 7-12-27 April 23, 2018 
scda_85 Map of construction activity at the three intakes and Meadows Slough April 23, 2018 
scda_86 Testimony of Frank Morgan April 23, 2018 
scda_87 Statement of Qualifications for Frank Morgan April 23, 2018 
scda_100 Testimony of Chris Kinzel April 23, 2018 
scda_101 Statement of Qualifications for Chris Kinzel  April 23, 2018 
scda_102 WaterFix FEIR/S Excerpts April 23, 2018 
scda_103 United States National Marine Fisheries Service California WaterFix Biological Opinion Excerpts April 23, 2018 
scda_104 Figure M15-4, page 4 of 8, California WaterFix FEIR April 23, 2018 
scda_106 SR 12 Realignment / Rio Vista Bridge Preliminary Study April 23, 2018 
scda_107 SR-12 Comprehensive Evaluation and Corridor Management Plan  April 23, 2018 
scda_125 Testimony of Rune Storesund April 23, 2018 
scda_126 Statement of Qualifications for Rune Storesund April 23, 2018 
scda_127 Mr. Peter Faust Letter from Malcom Drilling Company April 23, 2018 
scda_130 Testimony of Russel Ooms April 23, 2018 
scda_131 Statement of Qualifications for Russel Ooms  April 23, 2018 
scda 131-errata Statement of Qualifications for Russel Ooms - errata  April 23, 2018 
scda_150 Testimony of Bill Wells April 23, 2018 
scda_151 Statement of Qualifications for Bill Wells April 23, 2018 
scda_152 Hall Schell, Dawdling on the Delta April 23, 2018 
scda_200 Testimony of Brent Haddad Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_201 Statement of Qualifications for Brent Haddad Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_202 "Modernizing the System: California WaterFix Financing and Cost Allocation", Third Policy Paper prepared for Metropolitan Water District Board of Directors, Fall 2017 Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_203 "Modernizing the System: California WaterFix Operations", Second Policy Paper prepared for Metropolitan Water District Board of Directors, Fall 2017 Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_204 "Modernizing the System: California WaterFix Physical Infrastructure", First Policy Paper prepared for Metropolitan Water District Board of Directors, Fall 2017 Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_205 BDCP November 2013 Draft FEIR/S, Excerpt "Alternatives to Take"  Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_206 BDCP November 2013 Draft FEIR/S, Excerpt Appendix 9.A "Economic Benefits of the BDCP and Take Alternatives" Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_207 Biological Assessment Appendix 5.A-2 Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_208 BDCP Alternative Takes Brochure Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_209 BDCP Appendix 9.A "Economic Benefits Brochure" Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_210 California State Auditor, 2017. The Unexpected Complexity of the California WaterFix Project Has Resulted in Significant Cost Increases and Delays. (October) Report 2016-132. Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_211 Flyvbjerg, B. 2007. Policy and planning for large-infrastructure projects: problems, causes, and cures. Environment and Planning B: Planning and design 34: 578-97. Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_212 Flyvbjerg, B., Holm, M., and Buhl, S. 2002. Underestimated Costs in Public Works Projects: Error or Lie? Journal of the American Planning Association. Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_213 Mavin, 2014.  BDCP vs. local water supply alternatives: Dr. David Sunding reviews the alternative supply analysis for Metropolitan’s Bay- Delta committee. Mavin’s Notebook Blog post dated July 28.  Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_214 Metropolitan Water District of Southern California, 2017d.  Fiscal Years 2016/17 and 2017/18 Cost of Service for Proposed Water Rates and Charges.   Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_215 Metropolitan Water District of Southern California, 2017e.  2016/17 and 2017/18 Biennial Budget: State Water Project. Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_216 Metropolitan Water District of Southern California, 2016. 2015 Urban Water Management Plan.   Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_217 Michael, J. 2016. Benefit-Cost Analysis of The California WaterFix Center for Business & Policy Research, University of the Pacific (August). Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_218 Michael, J. 2013. Comments on the BDCP Benefit-Cost Analysis, (February 6) Downloaded November 17, 2017 Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_219 San Luis & Delta-Mendota Water Authority and State Water Contractors, 2015.  Comments on the Bay Delta Conservation Plan/California WaterFix Partially Recirculated Draft Environmental Impact Report/Supplemental Draft Environmental Impact Statement. Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_220 Sunding, D. 2016. California WaterFix Economic Analysis, Slide presentation (October 27).  Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_221 Sunding, D. 2015. Draft CalWater Fix Economic Analysis prepared for the California Natural Resources Agency by Dr. David Sunding, dated November 15, 2015. Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_222 Sunding, D. 2014, BDCP Costs and Economic Evaluation. California Water Law Conference presentation slides (June 12). Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_223 U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, County of Los Angeles Department of Public Works, and Los Angeles Flood Control District, 2014.  Los Angeles Basin Stormwater Conservation Study, Task 2: Water Supply and Demand Projections.  Withdrawn 3/21/2018
scda_224 Obegi, D. 2017.  Issue Brief: Mismatched: A Comparison of Future Water Supply and Demand for the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California and its Member Agencies.  (September) IB: 17-08-B.  Natural Resources Defense Council. Withdrawn 3/21/2018

 

Part 2 - Rebuttal

Exhibit No. Exhibit Description Date Accepted into Evidence* or Withdrawn
scda_300 Qualifications of Frank Morgan August 27, 2018
scda_301 Testimony of Frank Morgan August 27, 2018
scda_302 Photograph of aquatic weeds clogging boat prop August 27, 2018
scda_303 Photograph of aquatic weeds hindering navigation August 27, 2018
scda_304 Photograph of egeria densa with microsystis August 27, 2018
scda_305 FEIR Figure 3-4 eastern tunnel alignment  August 27, 2018
scda_306 FEIR Figure 3-9 Alternative 4A tunnel alignment August 27, 2018
scda_307 Qualifications of Bill Wells August 27, 2018
scda_308 Testimony of Bill Wells August 27, 2018
scda_309 Photograph of boats anchored at Potato Slough bedrooms August 27, 2018
scda_310 Photograph of boats anchored at Potato Slough bedrooms August 27, 2018
scda_311 Photograph of boats anchored at Potato Slough bedrooms August 27, 2018
scda_312 Photograph of boats anchored at Potato Slough bedrooms August 27, 2018
scda_313 Photograph of boats anchored at Potato Slough bedrooms August 27, 2018
scda_314 Photograph of boats anchored at Potato Slough bedrooms August 27, 2018
scda_315 Photograph of boats anchored at Potato Slough bedrooms August 27, 2018
scda_316 Photograph of boats anchored at Potato Slough bedrooms August 27, 2018
scda_317 Photograph of Tower Park Resort and Bouldin Island levee August 27, 2018
scda_318 Photograph of Tower Park Resort deck, restaurant, ice cream parlor August 27, 2018
scda_319 Photograph of Tower Park Grille August 27, 2018
scda_320 Photograph looking over levee from Tower Park Resort onto Bouldin Is. August 27, 2018
scda_321 Photograph looking over levee from Tower Park Resort onto Bouldin Is. August 27, 2018
scda_322 Photograph looking over levee from Tower Park Resort onto Bouldin Is. August 27, 2018
scda_323 Photograph looking over levee from Tower Park Resort onto Bouldin Is. August 27, 2018
scda_324 Photograph of children playing at Tower Park beach August 27, 2018
scda_325 Photograph of children playing at Tower Park beach August 27, 2018
scda_326 Google Earth image Potato Slough Barge Dock August 27, 2018
scda_327 Google Earth image Tower Park Resort August 27, 2018
scda_328 Google Earth Image Tower Park Children's Beach August 27, 2018
scda_350 Qualifications of Michael Brodsky August 27, 2018
scda_351 Testimony of Michael Brodsky August 27, 2018
scda_352-1 Rio Vista Bass Derby Boater Surveys August 27, 2018
scda_352-2 Rio Vista Bass Derby Boater Surveys August 27, 2018
scda_352-3 Rio Vista Bass Derby Boater Surveys August 27, 2018
scda_352-4 Rio Vista Bass Derby Boater Surveys August 27, 2018
scda_352-5 Rio Vista Bass Derby Boater Surveys August 27, 2018

 

Part 2 - Sur-Rebuttal

Exhibit No. Exhibit Description Date Accepted into Evidence* or Withdrawn
     

* For a complete account of testimony and exhibits that have been admitted into evidence, please see the Ruling Page for the corresponding ruling date and/or Transcript Page for the corresponding transcript date.