Petition Requesting Changes in Water Rights of The Department of Water Resources and U.S. Bureau of Reclamation for the California WaterFix Project Hearing

File Transfer Protocol Site Information

The State Water Board developed a secure File Transfer Protocol (FTP) website where parties to the hearing should upload their exhibits and parties can download the exhibits submitted by other parties. Each party on the service list will be provided a party-specific account with a username and password before their exhibit submittal deadline. All parties to the hearing will also have access to a shared account on the FTP site, which will allow parties to view and download other parties' exhibits, but only after the exhibit submittal deadline. The shared account is accessible at https://ftp.waterboards.ca.gov/?u=water fix download&p=waterfix123.

Part 1 | Part 1 - Rebuttal | Part 1 - Sur-Rebuttal | Part 2 | Part 2 - Rebuttal | Part 2 - Sur-Rebuttal

• Opening Statement
• Snug Harbor Resorts Exhibit Identification Index
• Snug Harbor Resorts Revised Exhibit Identification Index - 09/30/2016
• Snug Harbor Resorts Exhibit Identification Index - Revised 12/07/2016
• Snug Harbor Resorts Letter Re: Submission of Exhibit List for Entry into Evidence - 12/15/2016
• Snug Harbor Resorts Exhibit Identification Index - (Received 12/15/2016) Revised 12/30/2016
• Snug Harbor Resorts' Exhibit Identification Index - 3/23/2017
• Snug Harbor Resorts’ Exhibit Identification Index - 5/15/2017
• Snug Harbor Resorts’ Exhibit Identification Index - 5/22/2017
• Snug Harbor Resorts' Letter Re: Submission of Exhibit List for Entry into Evidence and Notice of Withdrawal of Exhibits and Confirmation of Previously Admitted Exhibits - 5/28/2017
• Snug Harbor Resorts' Exhibit Identification Index - 5/28/2017
• Snug Harbor Resorts’ Exhibit Identification Index - 6/8/2017
• Snug Harbor Resorts' Letter Re: Submission of Exhibit List for Entry into Evidence – 7/12/2017
• Snug Harbor Resorts’ Exhibit Identification Index - 7/12/2017
• Snug Harbor Resorts’ Exhibit Identification Index - 11/30/2017
• Snug Harbor Resorts' Exhibit Identification Index - 12/07/2017
• Snug Harbor Resorts’ Exhibit Identification Index - 1/11/2018
• Snug Harbor Resorts’ Errata Statement - 1/11/2018
• Snug Harbor Resorts’ Exhibit Identification Index - 3/16/2018
• Snug Harbor Resorts’ Exhibit Identification Index - 4/16/2018
• Snug Harbor Resorts’ Notice of Withdrawal of Exhibits - 4/16/2018
• Snug Harbor Resorts' Exhibit Identification Index - 4/18/2018
• Snug Harbor Resorts’ Exhibit Identification Index - 4/25/2018
• Snug Harbor Resorts’ Exhibit Identification Index - 7/16/2018
• Snug Harbor Resorts, LLC Exhibit Identification Index- 8/28/18

 

Part 1 - Snug Harbor Resorts, LLC

Exhibit No.	Exhibit Description	Date Accepted into Evidence* or Withdrawn
SHR-2	SHR History and photo summary & “Best Small Park 2001”, and permits. Delta Recreation maps - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-5	1960 DWR Water Bulletin No. 76 “Delta Water Facilities”	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-6 SHR-6f	1908 description of flows on SS and Sac in dry year-highlighted 1908 Full Description to accompany Survey of the Sacramento River submitted to US House of Representatives: Letter from the Secretary of War. Plus maps	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-6-1	1908 Survey showing lower Steamboat Slough - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-6-2	1908 Survey showing middle section of Steamboat Slough
SHR-6-3	1908 Survey showing upper section of Steamboat Slough - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-6-4	1908 Survey showing area of Walnut Grove - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-6-5	1908 Survey showing area of Courtland
SHR-6-6	1908 Survey showing area of Clarksburg - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-6-7	1908 Survey showing area of Isleton
SHR-7 shr-7large shr-7largeposter	2013 Water Portfolio Inflow Outflow Delta (screen print) larger sizeSHR-7detail includes pie charts showing graphically the unaccounted for flow data - Withdrawn 12/30/2106 (SHR-7large)
SHR-9	2010 Historical Fresh Water and Salinity Conditions in the Western Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta and Suisun Bay	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-9page5	Graph showing history of diversions, exports and storage from page 5Of SHR-9 - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-9b	Conclusion statement of SHR-9
SHR-10	1935 Soils Map of the Sacramento San Joaquin Delta Area, Henry G. Knight, Chief, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Bureau of Chemistry and Soils
SHR-11	Data gaps: study on CDEC missing data by N. Suard 4-8-2014
SHR-13 SHR-13large	Data gaps: study on CDEC accuracy poster format and flow chart from CDEC screen prints
SHR-16	Resolution No 68-16 SWRCB Statement of Policy with Respect to Maintaining High Quality of Waters in California
SHR-17	Map of Delta area water rights (screen print from Waterboards site) Staff Note: Per the Ruling Dated February 21, 2017, Only Slide One is Admitted into the Evidentiary Record	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-18	1911 Map of Drinking Water wells in the upper Central Valley USGS survey of Water Supply, Plate 5 - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-20	Slide set of water quality issues in the North Delta with photos by N.Suard
SHR-21	Slides for arsenic in groundwater questions-modeling	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-22	Drinking water and salinity
SHR-23	Chart of minimum flows with Tunnels operating; information not provided by DWR
SHR-23b	Information on flow data gaps for March 2014, sent to USACE
SHR-24	Graphic of aquifer recharge (screen print from BDCP docs)	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-25	2004 Public Health Goals for Chemicals in Drinking Water: Arsenic - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-26	USGS Analysis on the Occurrence of Arsenic in Ground-Water 2000	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-27	SWRCB, Division of Water Quality Gama program: Arsenic	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-28	2005 Delta Region Drinking Water Quality Management Plan	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-29	Anti-degredation policy	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-29h	Anti-degredation policy, highlighted text - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-31	Screen print, current SWRCB flow requirements-SWRCB Resolution No. 2010-0039
SHR-31f	SWRCB full documentSHR
SHR-32	Over-allocation of flows from the Sacramento River-screen print
SHR-33	100 years of California’s water rights system: patterns, trends and uncertaintyTheodore E Grantham and Joshua H ViersCenter for Watershed Sciences, University of California, 1 Shields Avenue, Davis, CA 95616, USASchool of Engineering, University of California, 5200N. Lake Road, Merced, CA 95343, USA http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/9/8/084012/pdf - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-34	2005 USGS Study of Arsenic in drinking water in the Central Valley, Page 27 map
SHR-34f	Full study	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-35	2011 USGS Study of Arsenic in drinking water in the Central Valley, page 38 map
SHR-35f	Full study	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-39e	DSM2 hydrology and bathymetry data timeline and with addition of missing subsurface flow diversion structures
SHR-39wf	WF map of DSM2 grid	Ruling dated February 21, 2017
SHR-39wf2	WF map of DSM2 with elevation and bathymetry updated 2016 Staff Note: Per the Ruling Dated February 21, 2017, Only SHR-39wf is Admitted into the Evidentiary Record
SHR-40	Bathymetry development presentation slides by Aaron Blake, USGS
SHR-40f	"Garbage in, garbage out" 2007
SHR-41	Links to barriers planning-pdf of webpage at snugharbor.net timeline - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-42	Map of Bench Studies on Steamboat Slough under BDCP/CalFed
SHR-43	2016 DSM2 Bathymetry update slide
SHR-50	Tidal and River Datums in the Sacramento River
SHR-63	Appendix 9J-Full document Delta Passage Model - Revised 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-64	USBR 2008 Delta Passage Model map - Revised 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-65	USBR Delta Passage Model flow and acres chart - Revised 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-66	Yolo Bypass Salmonid Habitat Restoration Implementation Plan
SHR-67	Salmon extinction chart by USBR-NOAA - Revised 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-67b	Salmon extinction map by USBR-NOAA - Revised 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-68	2500 cfs Red Bluff Diversion news article - Revised 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-69	“What caused the Sacramento River fall Chinook stock collapse?2009 Study - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-75	Timeline and history of uses of property at Snug Harbor
SHR-76	Statement of Permits and water rights & use
SHR-77	Graph of drinking water quality decline-SHR example	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-78	Steamboat Slough History - Revised 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-79	Ryer Island statement of points of diversion-riparian - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-80	CALFED timeline & Water Exports
SHR-81	Location in NorCal-map
SHR-82	Well and water quality data for SHR (example of incorrect SWRCB data)
SHR-83	Screen print of GeoTrackerGama map of Public Water Systems in Bay and Delta area
SHR-84	Bottleneck on Steamboat Slough and channel bench impacts
SHR-101	Powerpoint used in Part1 hearing: Overview of WaterFix
SHR-102	Powerpoint used in Part 1 hearing: Tunnel / Engineering Note: Per the Ruling Dated February 21, 2017, Only Slide Twenty Seven is Admitted into the Evidentiary Record	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-103	Powerpoint used in Part 1 hearing: Operations-impacts to water, navigation, flows Staff Note: Per the Ruling Dated February 21, 2017, Only Specific Slides are Admitted into the Evidentiary Record	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-104	Powerpoint used in Part 1 hearing: Modeling Staff Note: Per the Ruling Dated February 21, 2017, Only Specific Slides are Admitted into the Evidentiary Record	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-105	Policy statement on behalf of Snug Harbor Resorts, LLC
SHR-106	Powerpoint of SHR and North Delta photos
SHR-107	Opening statement for Case in Chief
SHR-108	Case in Chief for Snug Harbor Resorts, LLC	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-109	Statement of qualifications witness Nicole S. Suard
SHR-110	Copy of Protest form filed
SHR-200	1908 Survey of the Sacramento River (Including Steamboat Slough) Hogsback Shoals section - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-203	List of links for History of Steamboat Slough and salmon migration
SHR-204	Travel to Sacramento Via Delta Waterways: Steamboat Slough focusVideo: http://snugharbor.net/old_sacramento_river-video.html
SHR-205	Hall Irrigation map of the Delta	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-206a	1982 Geologic Maps of the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta by Brian F. Atwater “Courtland” (Upper Steamboat, Sutter Slough)
SHR-206b	1982 Geologic Maps of the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta by Brian F. Atwater “Isleton” (Steamboat Slough by Snug Harbor) Notations added
SHR-206c	1982 Geologic Maps of the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta by Brian F. Atwater “Rio Vista” (Steamboat Slough and Sacramento River Confluence)
SHR-208	Scanned pages from 1935 Paddle Wheel Days in California by Jerry MacMullen - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-209	1873 Board of Commissioners on Irrigation, Map of the San Joaquin, Sacramento and Tulare Valleys	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-210	1895 Steamboat Slough map showing Hogs Back and “Charleston” island (portion of map)	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-211	1945 Central Valley Basin Water Resources Development-USBR	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-212 SHR-212a	Excerpts: 1862 view of Steamboat Slough and Sacramento River by James M. Hutchings, and enlargement of one graphic from the book
SHR-213	Excerpts from references to travel on Steamboat Slough in the 1850’s to 1900 - 1935 Paddle Wheel Days in California by Jerry MacMullen highlighted
SHR-214	1848 to 1900 Shipwrecks on Steamboat Slough of the Sacramento Delta Region: Summary from 1986 State Lands Commission study of historic Shipwrecks in the North Delta Region
SHR-215	1930 State Water Plan, Bulletin No. 25, Publications of the Division of Water Resources, Report to the Legislature of 1931	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-216	Historical Timeline and links published 2012 for reference by N. Suard, Snug Harbor Resorts, LLC - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-217	The Settlement Geography of the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, , John Thompson, December 1957
SHR-218	1854 Sacramento River map, Henry Lange author (section of map)Full map at David Rumsey.com - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-220	1923 Steamboat Captain’s map of the Sacramento River Delta landings (section of a 60” long map)
SHR-221	1908 Sacramento River and Steamboat Slough minimum flows
SHR-222	Excerpts from James M. Hutchings 1862 book on “Scenes of Wonder and Curiosity”, including review of quantity of salmon on the Sacramento River. 22 pages
SHR-223	1975 Bulliten No 192 “Plan for Improvement of Delta Levees” (exerpt of)
SHR-250	2014 lawsuit filed related to rice growing and arsenic - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-251	STATE OF CALIFORNIA Drinking Water State Revolving Fund - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-252	Map of Stimulated Wells, FrackTracker
SHR-253	2014 low tide photos: impacts
SHR-254	MWD Southern California’s Integrated Water Resources Plan 1996 - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-255	Surplus Water Graphic
SHR-256	2007 BDCP Conservation Strategy (notation for Steamboat Slough)
SHR-258	OCAP Chapter 1, 2008, Summary of Legal Rights - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-259	2011 CALFED Update-funding - Revised 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-319	Timeline of Actions Affecting Water Quality
SHR-350	DWR chart provided via email on 8-25-16, received 8-26-16	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-351	NSS statement of receipt of DWR chart
SHR-352	DWR chart provided bia email on 8-26-16
SHR-353	DWR-SHR email series regarding DWR chart - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-381	Critical Year comparison
SHR-385	A&E requirement and screen print - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-386	Water Code Part 1.5 regarding 5-year reporting requirement: Delta outflows
SHR-388	A&E Delta Outflow from 8-29-16
SHR-389	Steamboat Slough Data gap 2016
SHR-389-errata	Steamboat Slough Data gap 2016 - errata Staff Note: Per the Ruling Dated February 21, 2017, Only Specific Slides are Admitted into the Evidentiary Record	Ruling Dated February 21, 2017
SHR-390	Study of water missing flows: "Where did the water go?"
SHR-391	Mapped New Intakes affecting Delta flows (poster format)
SHR-392	2007 Delta Water Quality study-CALFED Bay-Delta Program
SHR-393	2005 Delta Water Quality plan-Solano - Withdrawn 12/30/2016
SHR-394	Historical diversion to 2005 – screen print
SHR-395	BDCP Key Decisions/Products Schedule 1-4-2010 - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-396	BDCP-CALFED 10 Year Action Plan 2006 - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-397	CALFED Bay-Delta Program Year 8 Funding-page 4 - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-398	USBR-Increase in exports 2010
SHR-400	2013 California Water Plan Update, screen prints review
SHR-402	2014-2015 Treatment Study - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-403	1911 well map - Withdrawn 12/30/2016
SHR-404	Yolo Bypass restoration map
SHR-405	2007 Bathymetry map-DWR - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016
SHR-406	Dayflow 2014 data
SHR-500	Statement of Verification of Documents Uploaded by N. Suard
SHR-501	SHR List of Exhibits - Withdrawn 12/30/2016	Withdrawn December 30, 2016

 

Part 1 - Rebuttal

Exhibit No.	Exhibit Description	Date Accepted into Evidence* or Withdrawn
SHR-354	Map (Withdrawn 5/10/2017)
SHR-359	Review of DSM2 Bathymetry Update data
SHR-360	Screen Print of CDEC map showing Ryer Island and Steamboat Slough area edited to included locat
SHR-362	Graphics from flow data provided by DWR located in SHR-350
SHR-363	Graphic compiled from DWR-901 and SHR-350 for Monitoring Stations SSS, SUS, SXS, SOI and SRV
SHR-364	Graphics compiles using screen prints of USGS Rio Vista monitoring station and DWR-650
SHR-365	Graphics compiled from online resources to determine sensitive crops
SHR-367	Graphic comparing flow at monitoring station SSS in September 2015 to EC at that same time
SHR-368	DWR-316 Salinity Conversion Table with dotted line to show 1 ppt to EC relationship
SHR-369	CDEC chart showing Peak EC at monitoring station SXS in September 2015
SHR-370	CDED and DWR monitoring stations for lower Sacramento River at SOI showing EC Sept
SHR-407	BDCP Graphic of salinity impact from proposed reduced flows for BDCP conveyance plan.
SHR-502	Rebuttal Testimony of Nicole Suard
SHR-502-Revised	Rebuttal Testimony of Nicole Suard – Revised 5/22/2017
SHR-502-Staff-Revised	Rebuttal Testimony of Nicole Suard – Staff Revised 5/24/2017

 

Part 1 - Sur-Rebuttal

Exhibit No.	Exhibit Description	Date Accepted into Evidence* or Withdrawn
SHR-360-Errata	CDEC screen print showing monitoring stations on Steamboat Slough and Sacramento River	Ruling Dated August 10, 2017
SHR-363-Errata	Modeled Projected Drinking Water Quality of Steamboat Slough between the Monitoring Station during low flow months	Ruling Dated August 10, 2017
SHR-363-2	USGS Sacramento River flow at Rio Vista in 2015 and EC ranges	Ruling Dated August 10, 2017
SHR-363-3	CDEC chart of EC on Steamboat Slough at station SUS compared to flows of September 2015	Ruling Dated August 10, 2017
SHR-363-4	CDEC chart of EC on Steamboat Slough at Station SXS compared to flows of September 2015	Ruling Dated August 10, 2017
SHR-363-5	CDEC chart of EC on Sacramento River at station SOI compared to flows of September 2015	Ruling Dated August 10, 2017
SHR-364	DWR-650 compared to USGS flow chart for Sacramento River at Rio Vista in September, October 2015	Ruling Dated August 10, 2017
SHR-504	Written Sur-Rebuttal Testimony of Nicole S Suard for AHR	Ruling Dated August 10, 2017
SHR-504-Errata	Sur-rebuttal testimony of Nicole S Suard for SHR	Ruling Dated August 10, 2017
SHR-715	July 2014 Suard comments to National Marine Fisheries Service	Ruling Dated August 10, 2017
SHR-716	November 2015 Suard slides from presentation on water quality impacts from tunnels plans	Ruling Dated August 10, 2017
SHR-723	March 2009 Suard comments on BDCP to Ms. Delores Brown	Ruling Dated August 10, 2017
SHR-730	June 17, 2010 BDCP Physical Modeling Update	Ruling Dated August 10, 2017

 

Part 2

Exhibit No.	Exhibit Description	Date Accepted into Evidence* or Withdrawn
SHR-2-1	Nicole Suard Qualifications	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR 2-11	Nicole Suard testimony
SHR-2-11-errata	Nicole Suard testimony - errata
SHR-2-11-errata 2	Nicole Suard testimony - errata 2	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-13	Timeline of development for Snug Harbor	Not accepted per Ruling Letter dating January 4, 2018
SHR-2-14	Delta Timeline
SHR-2-16	Califonia WaterFix Overview for Kern County found online 2017	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-17	Summary of Impacts from BDCP 2013 as a reference example	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-18	Delta Conveyance History
SHR-2-19	Portion of Sacramento San Joaquin Delta Atlas by DWR, 1978 accessed online at http://water.ca.gov	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-20	Slides: Sacramento San Joaquin Delta: It Depends on Who Is Counting and What Type of Recreation
SHR-2-21	Delta Vision Context Memo 2007-Recreation by David Mitchell dated June 12, 2007	Not accepted per Ruling Letter dating January 4, 2018
SHR-2-21-F	Excerpts of the Delta Vision Context Memo 2017	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR 2-22	CF&W Yolo Bypass Planning Presentation 2008-12 Million Recreation Users Per Year in The Delta
SHR-2-23	WaterFix Tunnel Mapbook-Edited to emphasize select topic areas	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-24	1937 Snug Harbor from the air	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-25	Delta Flood Timeline	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-26	A Special Report on Fishing and Boating	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-27	2017:  How Many People Live, Work or Plan in The Delta That Would Be Impacted by Continued Excessive Diversions from the Sacramento River and Delta?
SHR-2-28	The Directionally Challenged DWR consultants: a review of the correct names for North Delta Islands and Waterways
SHR-2-28-2	The Directionally Challenged DWR consultants: a review of the correct names for North Delta Islands and Waterways	Not accepted per Ruling Letter dating January 4, 2018
SHR-2-29	Summary map showing the mistakes of the Directionally Challenged DWR consultants: 2--2 to 2017
SHR-2-30	Impacts:  CALTRANS in the Delta
SHR-2-31	Delta History & Water Conveyance Plans. Slide set compiled by N. Suard 2009-2014, updated 2017	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-101	Water Resources White Paper	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-102	Draft Development of Flow Criteria for the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Ecosystem	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-103	Developing Flow Prescriptions for the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-104	Delta Recreation incorrect data: Section 18, Draft Delta Plan EIR Program Report	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-105	Where's the Water? Power Point dated 5-15-14 by N. Suard review of noted flow issues in the North Delta Where's The Water?
SHR-2-106	The Value of Water in 21st Century California	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-107	Draft Part 3 of the Water Quality Control Plan for Inland Surface Waters, June 2017	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-108	Water Quality Slide Show-Waterboard	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-109	Scientific Basis Report in Support of New and Modified Requirements for Inflows from the Sacramento River et al 2017	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-110	SWRCB review of aquifer exemptions:  Solution legislation	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-111	Dangerous and Close:  Fracking Puts the Nations Most Vulnerable People at Risk	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-112	Economic Analysis of the Costs	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-113	Reclamation Water Supply & Yield Studies, pages 13,22,34,37,52	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-114	DWR Annual Peak Delta Inflows Chart	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-115	Example of CalTrans detour route Memorial Day Weekend 2011 https://youtube/04BBZvoU40Y	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-210	1950 Navigation on the Sacramento River and description of area	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-211	1852 map and Sketches and locations of Steamboat Slough in 1850's:  Island names noted	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-211R	1865 Delta Reference Map	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-212	Travel to Sacramento Via Delta Waterways in 1850: Steamboat Slough Focus: slide set compiled by N. Suard with references	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-213	Hutchings description of Salmon fishing at Steamboat and Sutter Sloughs
SHR-2-214	Steamboat Slough book excerpt:  Paddle Wheel days
SHR-2-215	Snug Harbor access and CalTrans: history of transportation issues 2000 to current	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-216	1876 survey map
SHR-2-217	Delta Reclamation History by John Thompson	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-218	1880s Reclamation map of the Delta:  Island and river names noted	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-219	1908 Survey of the Delta, Steamboat Slough and lower Sacramento maps; drought flows on Steamboat Slough	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-219-2	1908 Survey of the Sacramento River, notes to assist in reading the survey maps: scan of section of notes	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-219-3	1908 Survey of the Sacramento River, Sheet 11, with notes added in blue:  Sacramento River and upper Steamboat Slough Confluence (unclear map)	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-219-4	1908 Survey of the Sacramento River, Sheet 12, with notes added in blue:  Steamboat Slough at Hog Back (unclear map)	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-219-5	1908 Survey of the Sacramento River, Sheet 13, with notes added in blue:  Steamboat Slough at confluence with lower Sacramento River (unclear map)	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-220	1935 Soil Map of the Delta and 1913 road map	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-221	1937 aerial photo of Snug Harbor lands and homes
SHR-2-222	1945 subdivision map and new homes built	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-223	1935 Soil Map Sacramento San Joaquin Delta by Henry G. Knight, Chief, U.S. Department of Agriculture Bureau of Chemistry and Soil
SHR-2-224	1950's Surplus water plan: Graphic from 1960 Bulletin No 76, Delta Water Facilities 1950's Surplus water plan	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-225	1950's flood photo
SHR-2-226	1970's recreation & sea scouts on the Delta
SHR-2-227	1978 DWR plan for levee improvement
SHR-2-228	1978 Atwater maps of the Delta, including Steamboat Slough and lower Sacramento River
SHR-2-228-1	1978 Atwater Maps, Dept of the Interior, United States Geological Survey, with notes added in blue, sheet 4 of 21	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-228-2	1978 Atwater Maps, Dept of the Interior, United States Geological Survey	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-228-3	1978 Atwater Maps, Dept of the Interior, United States Geological Survey, with notes added in blue, sheet 10 of 21	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-228-4	1978 Atwater Maps, Dept of the Interior, United States Geological Survey, with notes added in blue, sheet 6 of 21	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-229	1986 Delta flood photo and water levels at Snug Harbor
SHR-2-230	SHR flood timeline
SHR-2-231	Hal Schell book excerpts Delta Dawdling, North Delta focus, Sea Scouts on Steamboat Slough and other photos	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-233-1	SHR "Best Small Park" designation and 2003 San Francisco Chronicle article "Ocean views and other wonders of Bay Area campsites" by Tom Stienstra	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-234	2005 NOAA Nautical Chart 18661 Sacramento and San Joaquin Rivers, with notation added	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-235	Liberty Island Reservoir, CALFED experiments on Steamboat Slough: map
SHR-2-236	Timeline of high water since the Liberty Island Reservoir was developed
SHR-2-238	Screen prints of pulse flows:  the fish studies
SHR-2-239	Screen prints of maps from the salmon migration studies
SHR-2-240	Photos of not enough water: dock damage
SHR-2-241	Impacts from insufficient flows: exposed vegetation, trees die, water quality decreases
SHR-2-242	2015 Summary of the Barriers Proposals and Possible Long Term Impacts From Barrier Installation (low flow and flood issues)	Withdrawn on April 25, 2018
SHR-2-243	Fish diversion methods and impacts from the LWD studies
SHR-2-244	Impacts from insufficients flows: invasive water weeds and loss of marina income
SHR-2-245	Impacts to Recreation from Low Flows and Pulse Flows: banks, roads, septics, costs, loss of income	Withdrawn on April 25, 2018
SHR-2-246	Impacts from floods: transportation and access
SHR-2-247	Unanswered Questions: Prospect Island (Water Weeds Nursery) and impacts to the Delta	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-248	DRMS Phase 1 incorrect Ryer Island data & efforts to correct:  cost impacts
SHR-2-249	Directionally Challenged consultants for DWR, SFEI, PPIC, DSC, NOAA, CalTrans:  Wrong maps of the Delta	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-249-errata	Directionally Challenged consultants for DWR, SFEI, PPIC, DSC, NOAA, CalTrans:  Wrong maps of the Delta	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-250	2012 The New Delta Plan: Graphic recreation of 1880s showing the future of Steamboat Slough and the Sacramento River	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-251	Low flows impacts to drinking water and irrigation water, docks, boating and recreation	Withdrawn per Letter dated May 4, 2018
SHR-2-251-errata	Low flows impacts to drinking water and irrigation water, docks, boating and recreation	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-252	Privately Owned Recreation Facilities, by County, Appendix 15A, BDCP Draft EIR/EIS March 2013	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-253	High flows caused by the Oroville maintenance failure by DWR: record flood at SHR:  leaseholders, staff costs.  Repairs to well, banks, roads	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-254	Effect of Tides, River Flow, and Gate Operations on Entrainment of Juvenile Salmon into the Interior Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta by R. Perry et al. 2015	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-255	How Delta Cross Channel operations affect Steamboat Slough Flows.	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-256	Historical Woody Forests of the Delta:  screen prints of historical sketches, maps and photos	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-257	Impacts to Recreation and Fishing from restoration projects at Prospect and Liberty Islands
SHR-2-258	Cache Slough Complex Impacts	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-259	Steamboat Slough Graphics
SHR-2-260	Delta Timeline History Links	Withdrawn per Letter dated April 16, 2018
SHR-2-261	Example-Wells and Septics impacts from Tunnel and Forebay Construction	Ruling Dated June 1, 2018
SHR-2-262	Noise carries in the Delta-slide showing location and photos of current major electrical construction work on Grand Island creating noise at Snug Harbor	Ruling Dated June 1, 2018
SHR-2-263	Questions for Panel 2-slides used (20 slides)	Withdrawn per Letter dated May 4, 2018
SHR-2-263-errata	Questions for Panel 2-slides used (20 slides)	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018
SHR-2-264	Slides used for questioning witnesses regarding impacts to recreation (30 slides)	Withdrawn per Letter dated May 4, 2018
SHR-2-264-errata	Slides used for questioning witnesses regarding impacts to recreation (30 slides)	Ruling Dated June 18, 2018

 

Part 2 - Rebuttal

Exhibit No.	Exhibit Description	Date Accepted into Evidence* or Withdrawn
SHR-253	2014 Low Tide photos showing impacts from low flows
SHR-701	Written testimony Part 2 rebuttal, Nicole S. Suard, Esq
SHR-701-R	Written testimony Part 2 rebuttal, Nicole S. Suard, Esq - Corrected by Hearing Staff according to the July 27, 2018 Ruling Letter
SHR-701-R2	Written testimony Part 2 rebuttal, Nicole S. Suard, Esq (revised on 8/27/18 by SHR)	September 10, 2018
SHR-702	Video review of low flow impacts on Steamboat Slough and Sacramento River  (includes SHR-253)	Withdrawn on August 27, 2018
SHR-703	Video review of flow splits in the North Delta waterways 2018 (original file unavailable)	Not admitted per Oral Ruling on August 27, 2018
SHR-703-Errata	Video review of flow splits in the North Delta waterways 2018 (file uploaded by staff on 8/27/18)	Not admitted per Oral Ruling on August 27, 2018
SHR-704	Ca Dept of Conservation 2018 New drilling permit-Staten Island	September 10, 2018
SHR-705	Ca Dept of Conservation map 610 Oil & Gas wells (North)	September 10, 2018
SHR-706	Ca Dept of Conservation map 614 Oil & Gas wells (North Delta area)	September 10, 2018
SHR-707	Online map of North Delta area gas wells and data sources (superseded by SHR-707-errata)
SHR-707-Errata	Online map of North Delta area gas wells and data sources	September 10, 2018
SHR-708	Excel Database of Ca Dept of Conservation Gas and Oil Wells, North area, with Delta counties highlighted
SHR-709	Impacts from insufficient fresh water flows into the Delta:  degraded drinking water aquifer: one cost example	Not admitted per Oral Ruling on August 27, 2018
SHR-710	Impacts from low flows and high flows on restoration projects	Withdrawn on August 27, 2018
SHR-711	Video of low tide boating in Walnut Grove to estimate WaterFix barge impact	Withdrawn on August 27, 2018
SHR-712	Screen prints of risk to humans from intakes	Withdrawn on August 27, 2018
SHR-713	Proposed new water quality, flow, level and temperature monitoring stations in the North Delta	September 10, 2018
SHR-714	Map of North Delta roads proposed to be prohibited for construction traffic use	September 10, 2018
SHR-715	Proposed New and Updated Monitoring Stations	Withdrawn on August 27, 2018
SHR-717	Update on Water Conversion formulas and CalSim III	Not admitted per Ruling Letter dated September 10, 2018
SHR-718	Advancement of Salinity and Flow Monitoring in the San Francisco Bay Delta Feb 2017	Not admitted per Ruling Letter dated September 10, 2018
SHR-719	July 2018 Framework for the Sacramento San Joaquin Delta Update to the Bay-Delta Plan	September 10, 2018
SHR-720	USBR/DWR Failure to account for decisions affecting humans:  video of impacts as example	Withdrawn on August 27, 2018
SHR-721	Photos from February 2017 flood due to Oroville actions by DWR	Withdrawn on August 27, 2018
SHR-722	Video representation of travel on Sacramento River and Steamboat Slough in 1850 by Tall Ship, Commander Ringold	Withdrawn on August 27, 2018
SHR-724	Photo of Sacramento River shipping and barge	September 10, 2018

 

 

Part 2 - Sur-Rebuttal

Exhibit No.	Exhibit Description	Date Accepted into Evidence* or Withdrawn

* For a complete account of testimony and exhibits that have been admitted into evidence, please see the Ruling Page for the corresponding ruling date and/or Transcript Page for the corresponding transcript date.