Marble Mountain Ranch-Cole Hearing Exhibits

List of Exhibits

California Department of Fish and Wildlife

Exhibit No. Description
CDFW-1 Declaration of Jennifer Bull
CDFW-2 Curriculum Vitae of Jennifer Bull
CDFW-3 March 17, 2000 letter from CDFW to State Water Resources Control Board ("State Water Board") re: Application 29449
CDFW-4 "Water temperature thresholds for coho salmon in a spring-fed river, Siskiyou County California," Stenhouse et al (California Fish and Game 98(1):19-37; 2012)
CDFW-5 Memorandum from Associate Fisheries Biologist Dennis Maria to CDFW's Stanshaw Creek File dated May 30, 2000
CDFW-6 Memorandum from Associate Fisheries Biologist Dennis Maria to CDFW's Stanshaw Creek File dated July 31, 2000
CDFW-7 "Findings Report for Stanshaw Creek Habitat and Instream Flow Assessment," Ross Taylor and Associates (January 2015)
CDFW-8 Arrest/Investigation Report dated September 29, 2000, prepared by Warden Brian Boyd
CDFW-9 Memorandum from CDFW to State Water Board dated November 20, 2001 re: State Water Board's complaint investigation relating to Application 29449
CDFW-10 Memorandum from CDFW to State Water Board dated February 7, 2007 re: State Water Board's complaint investigation relating to Application 29449
CDFW-11 Memorandum from CDFW to State Water Board dated October 15, 2009 re: small domestic use registration by Douglas Cole (No. D0309450)
CDFW-12 Letter from NOAA's National Marine Fisheries Service to State Water Board re:flow recommendation for Stanshaw Creek, dated August 3, 2016
CDFW-13 Declaration of Caitlin Bean
CDFW-14 Curriculum Vitae of Caitlin Bean
CDFW-15 Page 9.34 of "Recovery Strategy for California Coho Salmon" (February 2004) describing Task KR-UK-16
CDFW-16 CDFW letter to Douglas Cole, dated July 5, 2005
CDFW-17 2011 proposal by Will Harling, Mid Klamath Watershed Council, to Fisheries Restoration Grant Program ("FRGP") to fund coho habitat enhancement project on Stanshaw Creek (Proposal Identification Number-HI 154)
CDFW-18 2012 proposal by Will Harling, Mid Klamath Watershed Council, to FRGP to develop design alternatives to water and hydropower systems for Marble Mountain Ranch (Proposal Identification Number- PD 286)
CDFW-19 2012 proposal by Will Harling, Mid Klamath Watershed Council, for funding from Coho Enhancement Fund for the "Stanshaw Creek Water Conservation Assessment"
CDFW-20 Cascade Stream Solutions, "Marble Mountain Ranch Water Rights Investigation: Water Use Technical Memorandum" (November 18, 2014)
CDFW-21 Lennihan Law, "Marble Mountain Ranch Stanshaw Creek Water Rights Report" (September 1, 2014)
CDFW-22 2013 proposal by Will Harling, Mid Klamath Watershed Council, to FRGP re: Marble Mountain Ranch water system (Proposal Identification Number-PD 169)
CDFW-23 PD 169 Proposal Technical Review worksheet
CDFW-24 Declaration of Robert Holmes
CDFW-25 Curriculum Vitae of Robert Holmes
CDFW-26 "Short Communication: A Presumptive Standard for Environmental Flow Protection" (Richter et al. 2011)
CDFW-27 DFO. 2013. "Framework for Assessing the Ecological Flow Requirements to Support Fisheries in Canada." DFO Can. Sci. Advis. Sec. Sci. Advis, Rep. 2013/017
CDFW-28 Declaration of Curt Babcock
CDFW-29 Curriculum Vitae of Curt Babcock
CDFW-30 Streambed Alteration Agreement issued by CDFW to Marble Mountain Ranch for maintenance work (Notification No. 99-0040)
CDFW-31 Stipulation to Final Judgment and Stipulated Settlement Agreement in People v. Douglas Taylor Cole, et al., Siskiyou County Superior Court Case No. SC CV CV 00-1700
CDFW-32 Notification submitted by Douglas Cole under Fish and Game Code section 1602 on May 12, 2016 (Notification No. 1600-2016-0198-R1)
CDFW-33 Letter from CDFW to Douglas Cole dated May 16, 2016 re: Notification No. 1600-2016-0198-R1)
CDFW-34 Letter from CDFW to Douglas Cole dated February 6, 2017 re: May 16, 2016 letter
CDFW-35 Notification submitted by Douglas Cole under Fish and Game Code section 1602 received by CDFW on March 15, 2017 (Notification No. 1600-2017-0135-R1)
CDFW-36 Letter from CDFW to Douglas Cole dated April 14, 2017 finding Notification No.1600-2017-0135-R1 complete
CDFW-37 CDFW draft streambed alteration agreement to Marble Mountain Ranch (Notification No. 1600-2017-0135-R1) submitted to Douglas Cole on June 9, 2017
CDFW-38 Letter from Barbara Brenner to CDFW dated July 19, 2017 re: CDFW draft streambed alteration agreement to Marble Mountain Ranch (Notification No. 1600-2017-0135-R1)
CDFW-39 Email message from CDFW's Office of the General Counsel to Barbara Brenner memorializing agreement to postpone meeting to discuss measures in CDFW draft streambed alteration agreement to Marble Mountain Ranch (Notification No. 1600-2017-0135-R1) (with related email messages)

Douglas and Heidi Cole, Marble Mountain Ranch

Exhibit No. Description
MMR-1 Written Testimony of Douglas Cole
MMR-2 Point of Diversion and Diversion Photos
MMR-3 Water Storage Tank Photos
MMR-4 Hydroelectric Power Generator Photos
MMR-5 Recreational Pond Photos
MMR-6 Irving Creek Outfall Photos
MMR-7 Petition for Stay and Reconsideration of CAO
MMR-8 Screen and Box Culvert Photos
MMR-9 NMFS 2016 Bypass Flow Recommendation
MMR-10 Firefighter Efforts and Impacts Photos
MMR-11 Fire Service Ranch Use Declaration
MMR-12 Fiori Geosciences Reports
MMR-13 Report of Waste Discharge
MMR-14 2016 Proposed Water Quality Monitoring Plan
MMR-15 KASL Engineering Proposal
MMR-16 Financial Information
MMR-17 Written Testimony of Steven Cramer
MMR-18 Written Testimony of Jeff Meyer
MMR-19 Cost Estimates for Alternative Energy Systems
MMR-20 CDFW 1600 Agreement Status
MMR-21 Supplemental Testimony of Steven Cramer
MMR-22 Steven Cramer Data Table dated 10/2/2017 and 10/3/2017
MMR-23 Steven Crammer PowerPoint Presentation - Evaluation of Carrying Capacity and Limiting Factors for Production of Salmon and Steelhead
MMR-24 Timeline of Events
REBUTTAL EXHIBITS
MMR-25 Exhibit A (2006 - 2016 Receipts)
MMR-26 Exhibit B (Cole Expense Logs 1994 - 2017)
MMR-27 Douglas Cole Rebuttal Testimony

Karuk Tribe

Exhibit No. Description
KT-1 Qualification & Testimony of Leaf Hillman (October 6, 2017
KT-2 Qualification & Testimony of Craig Tucker (October 6, 2017)
KT-3 Email from Karuk to SWRCB re: MMR Physical Solutions (November 21, 2014)
KT-4 Qualification & Testimony of Toz Soto (October 6, 2017
KT-5 Stanshaw Creek Pool Pictures by Toz Soto (October 6, 2017)
KT-6 2002-2012 Presence/Absence Surveys for Juvenile Coho, Chinook, Steelhead in Mid-Klamath Tributaries (2012)
KT-7 Stanshaw Creek Habitat and Flow Assessment by Ross Taylor and Assoc. (January 2015)
KT-8 Mid-Klamath Tributary Streamflow Data by surveys by Six Rivers NF, Klamath NF, Karuk Tribe (1996-2012 estimates)
KT-9 Role of the Klamath River Mainstem Corridor in the Life History and Performance of Juvenile Coho Salmon (August 2013; Updated April 2016)

Klamath Riverkeeper

Exhibit No. Description
KR-1 WPLG, "Supplemental Information and Unresolved Issues Regarding Pre-1914 Appropriative Right Claims of Coles-Marble Mountain Ranch to Water from Stanshaw Creek" (February 20, 2015)
KR-2 Lennihan Law, "Marble Mountain Ranch Stanshaw Creek Water Rights Report" (September 1, 2014)
KR-3 Cascade Stream Solutions, "Marble Mountain Ranch Water Rights Investigation: Water Use Technical Memorandum" (November 18, 2014)
KR-4 Wing Solar & Wood Energy, "Cost Estimate for Solar Panels and Diesel Generator" (September 19, 2017)
KR-5 Aurora Power & Design, "Cost Estimate for Replacement Micro-Hydropower System" (September 28, 2017)
KR-6 Submission of Klamath Riverkeeper

National Marine Fisheries Service

Exhibit No. Description
NMFS-1 Written testimony Margaret Tauzer 
NMFS-2 Curriculum Vitae Margaret Tauzer 
NMFS-3 August 3, 2016 Letter from National Marine Fisheries Service to Barbara Evoy, State Water Resources Control Board
NMFS-4 Excel spreadsheet used to analyze Stanshaw Creek flows and demonstrate the bypass flows
NMFS-5 July 1, 2015 NMFS Instream Flow Recommendations for Marble Mountain Ranch Diversion
NMFS-6 Photographs of Stanshaw Creek
NMFS-7 Written testimony Shari Whitmore
NMFS-8 Curriculum Vitae Shari Whitmore
NMFS-9 Thesis Shari Whitmore
NMFS-10 Middle  Klamath River Population  Profile
NMFS-11 March 30, 2016 Douglas Cole email Request
NMFS-12 February 15, 2015 email Will Wharling to Margaret Tauzer
NMFS-13 Barnhart 1986 - Species Profiles: Life Histories and Environmental Requirements of Coastal Fiishes and Invertbrates (Pacific Southwest) 
NMFS-14 Bartholow 2005 - Recent Water Temperature Trends in the Lower Klamath River, California
NMFS-15 Belchik 1997 - Summer Locations and Salmonid Use of Cool Water Areas in the Klamath River Iron Gate Dam to Seiad Creek, 1996
NMFS-16 Bell and Duffy 2007 - Previously Undocumented Two-Year Freshwater Residency of Juvenile Coho Salmon in Prairie Creek, California
NMFS-17 Beschta et al 1987 - Stream Temperature and Aquatic Habitat: Fisheries and Forestry Interactions
NMFS-18 U. S. Bureau of Reclamation 2007 - Klamath River Thermal Refugia Study, 2006: Technical Memorandum No. 86-68290-01-07
NMFS-19 Brett 1952 - Temperature Tolerance in Young Pacific Salmon, Genus Oncorhynchus 
NMFS-20 Brewitt 2014 - Spatio-temporal temperature variation influences juvenile steelhead (Oncorhynchus mykiss) use of thermal refuges
NMFS-21 Chesney et al 2009 - Shasta River Juvenile Coho Habitat & Migration Study
NMFS-22 Coutant 1977 - Compilation of Temperature Preference Data
NMFS-23 Asarian 2013 - Synthesis of Continuous Water Quality Data for the Lower and Middle Klamath River, 2001-2011
NMFS-24 Gilbert 1912 - Bulletin of the United States Bureau of Fisheries Vol. XXXII 1912
NMFS-25 Hallett et al 2012 - Density of the Waterborne Parasite Ceratomyxa shasta and Its Biological Effects on Salmon
NMFS-26 Healey 1991 - Pacific Salmon Life Histories
NMFS-27 Holtby et al 1990 - Importance of Smolt Size and Early Ocean Growth to lnterannual Variability in Marine Survival of Coho Salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch)
NMFS-28 Leidy and Leidy 1984 - Life Stage Periodicities of Anadromous Salmonids in the Klamath River Basin, Northwestern California
NMFS-29 Federal Register /Vol. 64, No. 86 /Wednesday, May 5, 1999 /Rules and Regulations
NMFS-30 Myers et al 1998 - Status Review of Chinook Salmon from Washington, Idaho, Oregon, and California
NMFS-31 2014 Final Recovery Plan for the Southern Oregon/Northern California Coast Evolutionarily Significant Unit of Coho Salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch) Chapters 1 to 6
NMFS-32 NMFS 2016 5-Year Review: Summary & Evaluation of Southern Oregon/Northern California Coast Coho Salmon
NMFS-33 Peterson 1982 - Population Characteristics of Juvenile Coho Salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch) Overwintering in Riverine Ponds
NMFS-34 Poff et al. 1997 - The Natural Flow Regime - A paradigm for river conservation and restoration
NMFS-35 Rantz 1964 - Surface-Water Hydrology of Coastal Basins of Northern California
NMFS-36 Rantz 1968 - Average Annual Precipitation and Runoff in North Coastal California
NMFS-37 Ray et al 2012 - Relationship Between Temperature and Ceratomyxa shasta–Induced Mortality In Klamath River Salmonids
NMFS-38 Reiser and Bjornn 1979 - Influence of Forest and Rangeland Management on Anadromous Fish Habitat in the Western United States and Canada. 1. Habitat Requirements of Anadromous Salmonids
NMFS-39 Richter et al 1996 - A Method for Assessing Hydrologic Alteration within Ecosystems
NMFS-40 Richter et al 2011 -A Presumptive Standard for Environmental Flow Protection
NMFS-41 Sandercock 1991 - Life History of Coho Salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch)
NMFS-42 NMFS Exhibit List
NMFS-43 Stenhouse et al 2012 - Water temperature thresholds for coho salmon in a spring-fed river, Siskiyou County, California
NMFS-44 Strange 2011 - Salmonid Use of Thermal Refuges in the Klamath River: 2010 Annual Monitoring Study
NMFS-45 Taylor 2015 - Findings Report for Stanshaw Creek Habitat and Instream Flow Assessment
NMFS-46 Tschaplinski 1988 - The Use of Estuaries as Rearing Habitats by Juvenile Coho Salmon

Old Man River Trust

Exhibit No. Description
OMRT-1 Map showing property ownership and current and potential points of diversion.
OMRT-2 February 25, 2015 letter from Konrad Fisher to SWRCB addressing pre-1914 water right.
OMRT-3 Aurora Power & Design, "Cost Estimate for Replacement Micro-Hydropower System" (September 28, 2017)
OMRT-4 Photos of sediment discharge into Klamath River in February, 2008
OMRT-5 Photos of diversion and dewatered Stanshaw Creek, September, 2009
OMRT-6 Cascade Stream Solutions, "Marble Mountain Ranch Water Rights Investigation: Water Use Technical Memorandum" (November 18, 2014)
OMRT-7 Wing Solar & Wood Energy, "Cost Estimate for Solar Panels and Diesel Generator" (September 19, 2017)
OMRT-8 Energy Savers Home Energy Use Guide
OMRT-9 October 6, 2017 letter from Konrad Fisher with evidence and statements about Marble Mountain Ranch Cole Hearing
OMRT-10 Declaration from Phil Albers Jr
OMRT-11 Statement of qualifications for Derek Jackson with Aurora Power & Design

State Water Resources Control Board, Division of Water Rights Prosecution Team

Exhibit No. Description
WR-1 Draft Order
WR-2 Division request for hearing and draft order (August 30, 2016) 
WR-3 Letter Division to DCole re request for hearing with attachments (August 23, 2016)
WR-4 Water Right File Application 29449, Volume 1 - Submitted by reference by the Prosecution Team, pursuant to the Hearing Notice, section 6 subdivision (b), California Code or Regulations, title 23, section 648.3. Available at the SWRCB Records Unit
WR-5 Water Right File Application 29449, Volume 2 - Submitted by reference by the Prosecution Team, pursuant to the Hearing Notice, section 6 subdivision (b), California Code or Regulations, title 23, section 648.3. Available at the SWRCB Records Unit.
WR-6 Stanshaw Creek Complaints and Investigations File - Submitted by reference by the Prosecution Team, pursuant to the Hearing Notice, section 6 subdivision (b), California Code or Regulations, title 23, section 648.3. Available at the SWRCB Records Unit.
WR-7 Testimony of Taro Murano
WR-8 Statement of Qualifications for Taro Murano
WR-9 Testimony of Skyler Anderson
WR-10 Statement of Qualifications for Skyler Anderson
WR-11 NO EXHIBIT
WR-12 NO EXHIBIT
WR-13 Testimony of Stormer Feiler
WR-14 Statement of Qualifications for Stormer Feiler
WR-15 1867.03.25 Stanshaw claim (typed)
WR-16 1867.03.25 Stanshaw claim
WR-17 1965.05 Bulletin 94-6-I (1965)
WR-18 1965.05 Bulletin 94-6-II (1965)
WR-19 1977.08.03 Permit 20955 Mountain Home and progress reports
WR-20 1984.06.21 Water Right Decision 1600 - Submitted by reference by the Prosecution Team, pursuant to the Hearing Notice, section 6 subdivision (b), California Code or Regulations, title 23, section 648.3. Available at the SWRCB Records Unit or at https://www.waterboards.ca.gov/waterrights/board_decisions/adopted_orders/decisions/d1600_d1649/wrd1600.pdf.
WR-21 1988.09.07 Water Right Order 88-20 - Submitted by reference by the Prosecution Team, pursuant to the Hearing Notice, section 6 subdivision (b), California Code or Regulations, title 23, section 648.3. Available at the SWRCB Records Unit or at https://www.waterboards.ca.gov/waterrights/board_decisions/adopted_orders/orders/1988/wro88-20.pdf.
WR-22 1989.03.17 Application 29449
WR-23 1993.04.13 PKelly@KMTG to KMrowka @SWRCB re A29449
WR-24 1994.11.17 Letter from Division to Diverter re change in ownership
WR-25 1994.12.15. Assessors Parcel Map
WR-26 1994.12-15.Cole Grant Deed
WR-27 1995.04.25 Letter MGoss to Van Dyke @SWRCB re DWR Bulletin 94-6 May 1963
WR-28 1995.05.05 Letter MGoss to Van Dyke @SWRCB re flow measurements
WR-29 1998.01.16 Water Quality Control Plan for the North Coast Region Appendix 3 - temperature plan
WR-30 1998.06.05 Memo CMurray @SWRCB to file re MMR inspection
WR-31 1998.09.15 Letter HSchueller @SWRCB to Dcole re prior applications & pre-1914 claim
WR-32 1998.12.01 Statement of Diversion and Use S015022 - Douglas Cole
WR-33 1999.04.30 MMR 1600 Agreement
WR-34 1999.09.17 Small Domestic Registration D030945 - Douglas Cole
WR-35 2000.03.08 National Marine Fisheries Service Protest to Application 29449
WR-36 2000.03.09 US Forest Service Protest to Application 29449
WR-37 2000.03.17 California Department of Fish & Game Protest to Application 29449
WR-38 2000.03.20 James and Phylis Fisher Protest to Application 29449
WR-39 2000.03.20 Konrad Fisher Protest to application 29449
WR-40 2000.07.26 SWRCB Field Inspection
WR-41 2000.08.31 Statement of Diversion and Use S015230 - JW Fisher
WR-42 2000.09.25 California Sportfishing Protection Alliance Protest to Application 29449
WR-43 2000.10.03 Notice to Appear and report Doug Cole for Fish & Game Code violations
WR-44 2000.10.06 Complaint and TRO v Douglas Cole for F&G Code violations
WR-45 2000.11.14 Contact Report from RMiller to BBoyd DFG Warden
WR-46 2000.11.14 Contact Report from RMiller to LAllen re DFG injunction
WR-47 2000.11.14 Contact report with RMiller and DCole re DFG injuction
WR-48 2001.06.14 Complaint from Klamath Forest Alliance
WR-49 2001.06.22 Letter RMiller @SWRCB to KFisher re A29449
WR-50 2001.10.03 Stipulated Final Judgement and Settlement Agreement Cole-DFG
WR-51 2001.11.15 Letter NMFS to CRich @SWRCB re protest to Application 29449
WR-52 2001.11.20 Letter DFG to SWRCB re complaint and protest to Application 29449
WR-53 2002.05.23 SWRCB Inspection Report re complaints
WR-54 2002.07.08 Letter JBybee @NMFS to MContreras @Divison re complaint
WR-55 2002.08.22 Letter EAnton @SWRCB to DCole re complaints
WR-56 2005.07.05 Letter DKock @DFG to DCole re conditions for D030945
WR-57 2005.08.05 Letter SWRCB to Cole re domestic D030945 renewal
WR-58 2009.09.03 Letter KMrowka @SWRCB to GStacey @DFG re conditions for D030945R
WR-59 2009.10.15 Letter GStacey @DFG to KMrowka @SWRCB re Small Domestic D030945
WR-60 2009.12.31 USFS Special Use Permit for Outfitting and Guiding
WR-61 2010.05.28 Statement of Diversion and Use S016375 - Marble Mountain Ranch and supplemental statements
WR-62 2011.05 Water Quality Control Plan for the North Coast Region - Submitted by reference by the Prosecution Team, pursuant to the Hearing Notice, section 6 subdivision (b), California Code or Regulations, title 23, section 648.3. Available at egion 1 or at http://www.waterboards.ca.gov/northcoast/water_issues/programs/basin_plan/083105-bp/basin_plan.pdf.
WR-63 2012.02.07 Water Right Order 2012-0004 - Submitted by reference by the Prosecution Team, pursuant to the Hearing Notice, section 6 subdivision (b), California Code or Regulations, title 23, section 648.3. Available at the SWRCB Records Unit or at https://www.waterboards.ca.gov/waterrights/board_decisions/adopted_orders/orders/2002/wro2002-04.pdf.
WR-64 2012.03.30 Letter PCrader @SWRCB to DCole re A29449 public trust mitigation requirements
WR-65 2012.05.29 Letter BBrenner to MMcCarthy @SWRCB re A29449 extension
WR-66 2012.06.01 Email MMcCarthy @SWRCB to BBrenner re A029449
WR-67 2012.10.01 Letter BBrenner to MMCCarthy @SWRCB re MMR pre-1914 claim
WR-68 2012.11.02 Letter PCrader @SWRCB to Marble Mountain Ranch re A029449 & pre-1914 claim
WR-69 2012.11.29 Letter BBrenner to BRinker @SWRCB re S015022 Douglas Cole and S15022
WR-70 2013.01.07 Letter PCrader @SWRCB to Cole re cancellation A029449
WR-71 2013.06.26 Email JWilliams to KGale @DFW with attachments
WR-72 2013.09.27 Email JWilliams @SWRCB to KGale @DFW re DCole grant funding
WR-73 2014.01.14 Email JWilliams @SWRCB to KFisher re recent correspondence wDCole
WR-74 2014.01.28 Email TSoto @Karuk to JWilliams @SWRCB re data collection
WR-75 2014.01.28 KFisher Stanshaw Creek Video January 2014 (includes link to video)
WR-76 2014.01.29 Email JWilliams @SWRCB to KFisher re Stanshaw diversion video (linked video)
WR-77 2014.06.15 Letter KFisher to MLennihan & JHoward re water right report
WR-78 2014.06.21 D30945 Small Domestic Registration D030945 Renewal Doug Cole
WR-79 2014.07.15 Email JWilliams @SWRCB to MLennihan re MMR water right report
WR-80 2014.09.01 MMR Water Rights Report (Lennihan Report)
WR-81 2014.11.12 Email CTucker @Karuk to TMurano @SWRCB re MMR physical solutions
WR-82 2014.11.18 Cascade Water Rights Investigation Tech Memo
WR-83 2014.12.17 Stanshaw Creek Water Conservation Meeting Notes
WR-84 2014.12.29 Email BPagliuco @NOAA to SAnderson @SWRCB re Stanshaw fish kills
WR-85 2015.01.05 Email SAnderson @SWRCB to TSoto @Karuk re Stanshaw fish kills
WR-86 2015.01.12 Letter BBrenner to TMurano @SWRCB re comments on Lennihan MMR water rights report
WR-87 2015.12.03 Division of Water Rights MMR Report of Inspection
WR-88 2015.12.03 North Coast WQCB Notice of Violation
WR-89 2015.03.15 North Coast WQCB Report of Inspection
WR-90 2015.01.15 Email SAnderson @SWRCB to WHarling @MKWC re Stanshaw stakeholder meeting minutes
WR-91 2015.01.21 Email JSciancalepore to TMurano @SWRCB re Lennihan Report
WR-92 2015.01.26 Letter CTucker @Karuk to TMurano @SWRCB re Lennihan MMR water right report
WR-93 2015.01.28 Email TSoto @Karuk to SAnderson @SWRCB re Stanshaw fish kill wRoss Taylor Report
WR-94 2015.02.02 MMR Secretary of State filing
WR-95 2015.02.09 Email SAnderson @SWRCB to TSoto @Karuk re Stanshaw fish kill
WR-96 2015.02.17 Email TSoto @Karuk to Sanderson @SWRCB re flow record
WR-97 2015.02.17 Email TSoto @Karuk to SAnderson @SWRCB re Stanshaw data
WR-98 2015.02.20 Letter OMRT to ATauriainen @SWRCB re MMR pre-1914 claim
WR-99 2015.02.25 Letter KFisher to SWRCB re Stanshaw water rights & physical solutions
WR-100 2015.03.12 Email Tmurano @SWRCB to CTucker @Karuk re inspection report
WR-101 2015.04.15 Email GCurtis @DFW to SAnderson @SWRCB re MMR bypass flow
WR-102 2015.04.27 Email GCurtis @DFW to SAnderson @SWRCB re MMR bypass flow
WR-103 2015.06.04 Email TSoto @Karuk to SAnderson @SWRCB re fish kill
WR-104 2015.07.07 Email KFisher to TMurano @SWRCB re Stanshaw June flows
WR-105 2015.07.07 Email KFisher to TMurano @SWRCB re Stanshaw June flows
WR-106 2015.12.03 Region 1 Marble Mountain Ranch CAO Draft
WR-107 2015.12.22 Email KO'Ferrall @CW to DHenrioulle @WQCBR1 re NOV response extension
WR-108 2015.12.23 Email KPetruzzelli @SWRCB to KO'Ferrall @CW re extension
WR-109 2016.01.14 Stanshaw Stakeholders Mtg Notes
WR-110 2016.01.19 Letter BBrenner to KPetruzzelli @SWRCB re SWRCB & R1 reports & corrective actions
WR-111 2016.02.02 Email BSutter @SWRCB to TMurano @SWRCB re MMR drinking water
WR-112 2016.02.12 Letter KPetruzzelli @SWRCB to DCole re enforcement action
WR-113 2016.03.16 Email from MTauzer @NMFS to SAnderson re Stanshaw flow- voluminous attachment not printed
WR-114 2016.03.16 Email WHarling @MKWC to TMurano @SWRCB re Scope of Work and Budget for NFWF Grant # 040710
WR-115 2016.03.24 Letter BBrenner to KPetruzzelli @SWRCB re MMR corrective actions and time schedule
WR-116 2016.03.30 Email MTauzer @NFMS to SAnderson @SWRCB re flow recommendation
WR-117 2016.04.03 Email AButterfield @NFWF to SAnderson @SWRCB re MMR pipe grant
WR-118 2016.04.05 Mountain Home ROI Photo Log
WR-119 2016.04.05 Mountain Home ROI
WR-120 2016.04.09 Email BPagliuco @NOAA to SAnderson @SWRCB re MMR pipe grant
WR-121 2016.04.15 Email MTauzer @NMFS to SAnderson @SWRCB re flow recommendation - voluminous attachment not printed
WR-122 2016.04.15 Letter BBrenner to KPetruzzelli @SWRCB re MMR progress report
WR-123 2016.04.19 Email KFisher to SAnderson @SWRCB & stakeholders re POD change
WR-124 2016.04.20 Email KPetruzzelli @SWRCB to BBrenner @CW re MMR scope of work
WR-125 2016.04.21 Email JHoward to WHarling cc SWRCB and attachments # 2
WR-126 2016.04.21 Email JHoward to WHarling cc SWRCB and attachments #1
WR-127 2016.04.21 Email WHarling to KPetruzzeli re MMR water use
WR-128 2016.04.25 Email TMurano to BBrenner re MMR project proposal
WR-129 2016.05.06 Email BBrenner @CW to KPetruzzelli @SWRCB re MMR project proposal
WR-130 2016.05.09 email from MTauzer to SAnderson - voluminous attachment not printed
WR-131 2016.05.09 Email MTauzer @NMFS to SAnderson @SWRCB re bypass flow
WR-132 2016.05.12 Email BBrenner to KPetruzzelli re project proposal
WR-133 2016.05.12 Email MTauzer to KPetruzzelli re bypass flow
WR-134 2016.05.16 Letter DFW to Diverter re need for 1600 for act of diverting water
WR-135 2016.05.20 Letter BBrenner to KPetruzzelli re resource improvement update with attachments
WR-136 2016.05.20 Letter BBrenner to SBargsten @R1 re MMR pipe 401 application
WR-137 2016.05.20 Notice of Intent 401 Small Habitat Restoration Marble Mountain Ranch
WR-138 2016.06.09 Email TMurano @SWRCB to CBean @DFW et al re MMR pipe project permitting
WR-139 2016.06.13 Email JShannon @SWRCB to MMR re pipe project water quality certification
WR-140 2016.07.07 Email JHoward to SAnderson @SWRCB re MMR consumptive use demand
WR-141 2016.08.03 Letter NMFS to BEvoy re Stanshaw Creek Bypass Flow Recommendations
WR-142 2016.08.04 North Coast WQCB CAO R1-2016-0031 Douglas and Heidi Cole and Marble Mountain Ranch
WR-143 2016.08.04 North Coast WQCB Cleanup and Abatement Order Cover Letter
WR-144 2016.08.26 Letter BBrenner to KPetruzzelli re CAO R1-2016-0031
WR-145 2016.09.06 Letter BBrenner Request for Reconsideration Cleanup and Abatement Order
WR-146 2016.09.09 Letter BBrenner to SRLee @North Coast WQCB re Water Quality Sampling Plan
WR-147 2016.09.30 Letter BBrenner to JO'Hagan Progress Report
WR-148 2016.10.14 email from TSoto to SAnderson
WR-149 NO EXHIBIT
WR-150 2016.10.17 Letter BBrenner @CW to KPetruzzelli @SWRCB re draft order
WR-151 2016.10.18 Letter PWyles @SWRCB to BBrenner re acknowledgement of petition
WR-152 2016.10.18 North Coast WQCB Notice of Violation CAO R1-2016-0031
WR-153 2016.10.19 Email BPagliuco @NOAA to TMurano @SWRCB re MMR pipeline grant
WR-154 2016.10.26 Letter BBrenner to SFeiler re 2016.10.18 NOV
WR-155 2016.12.20 Letter Division Drinking Water to Cole re public water system status
WR-156 2017.01.04 Letter BBrenner re Marble Mountain January 2017 Progress Report
WR-157 2017.01.11 Letter BBrenner to KPetruzzellI re MMR responses to questions
WR-158 2017.01.17 Marble Mountain Ranch Declaration of public water system exemption
WR-159 2017.02.06 Letter DFW to DCole re need to notify for 1602
WR-160 2017.02.08 Letter BBrenner to KPetruzzelli re MMR time schedule
WR-161 2017.03.15 MMR 1600 Notification
WR-162 2017.03.17 North Coast WQCB NOV 2 and Response to Discharger 2016.08.26 letter re CAO
WR-163 2017.04.10 Letter BBrenner to KPetruzzelli re North Coast WQCB NOV No. 2
WR-164 2017.04.14 Letter DFW to Diverter re complete 1600 notification
WR-165 2017.04.24 Letter MSt.John to MMR re time schedule modification
WR-166 2017.06.19 Letter DFW to Diverter re Draft LSA
WR-167 2017.06.27 North Coast WQCB NOV 3 with attachments
WR-168 2017.06.30 Letter BBrenner to J'OHagan @SWRCB re MMR Progress Report
WR-169 2017.07.27 Email MTauzer to SAnderson re 2015 flow recommendations
WR-170 1991.08.22 Water Right Order 91-07 - Submitted by reference by the Prosecution Team, pursuant to the Hearing Notice, section 6 subdivision (b), California Code or Regulations, title 23, section 648.3. Available at the SWRCB Records Unit or at https://www.waterboards.ca.gov/waterrights/board_decisions/adopted_orders/orders/1991/wro91-07.pdf.
WR-171 1998.11.19 Water Right Order 98-08 - Submitted by reference by the Prosecution Team, pursuant to the Hearing Notice, section 6 subdivision (b), California Code or Regulations, title 23, section 648.3. Available at the SWRCB Records Unit or at https://www.waterboards.ca.gov/waterrights/board_decisions/adopted_orders/orders/1998/wro98-08.pdf.
WR-172 2016.11.15 Email KPetruzzelli to BBrenner re Questions and ATP information
WR-173 2016.02.19 Letter Divison to Douglas Cole re failure to file supplemental statement for S015022
WR-174 2013.01.30 Letter Division to Douglas Cole re failure to file Supplemental Statement for S015022
WR-175 2014.01.30 Letter Division to Douglas Cole re failure to file supplemental statment for S016375
WR-176 2014.08.01 Letter Division to Douglas Code re failure to file supplemental statement S016375 - final notice
WR-177 2016.08.01 JHoward Draft Report re Solutions and Preliminary Plans
WR-178 2015.01.06 Ecotourism at California's Dude Ranch
WR-179 2015.02.23 Sustainable Guest Ranching
WR-180 2015.03.09 Ten Benefits Of A Covered Riding Arena
WR-181 2015.04.27 Dare to Dream
WR-182 Building A Dude Ranch Cowboy Bunkhouse
WR-183 2017.09.13 Letter BBRenner to KPetruzzelli re NOV3
WR-184 Email WHarlling @MKWC to SAnderson @SWRCB re coho restoration project
WR-185 2016.06.03 Water Quality Control Plan Temperature Updates
WR-186 2017.09.22 from BAB to K. Petruzzelli re Ability to Pay and Quarterly Progress Report
WR-187 2011.01.25 Complaint re Marble Mountain Ranch
WR-188 2017.06.01 Emails SFeiler to TSoto and LCyr re Temp and Flow Data
WR-189 2017.06.27 Emails SFeiler to TSoto and LCyr re Temp and Flow Data
WR-190 2017.06.06 Email TSoto to SFeiler re 2009 Temp Data (voluminous attachment not printed)
WR-191 SFeiler Graph Using Temp Data From 2009.07.01
WR-192 USEPA National Management Measures to Control Nonpoint Source Pollution from Hydromodification
WR-193 Lennihan Report Supporting Documents
WR-198 Presentation of Opening Statement by Kenneth Petruzzelli
WR-199 Presentation - Taro Murano
WR-200 Presentation - Skylar Anderson
WR-201 Presentation - Stormer Feiler
REBUTTAL EXHIBITS
WR-194 Bryan Elder Memorandum-Financial Analysis - Marble Mountain Ranch
WR-195 Curriculum Vitae Bryan Elder
WR-196 PowerPoint presentation of MMR Financial Analysis
WR-197 Skylar Anderson MMR Diversion Ditch - second set of photographs

State Water Resources Control Board, Staff

Exhibit No. Description
SWRCB-1 Staff Annotated Map of Diversion Works Consistent with Testimony of Prosecution Team Witness, Skyler Anderson
SWRCB-2 Lidar Map of Project Location Annotated by Douglas Cole that Identifies Ravine and Capture Point Near Hydropower Facility
SWRCB-3 Property Boundaries Map Annotated by Konrad Fisher that Identifies Old Man River Trust Parcels and Locations of the Stanslaw Tributaries Serving OMRT, the MMR Lower Ditch Outlet, and the Occasionally Flooded Public Dirt Road